Saturday, December 19, 2015

Aamir Khan Vs Rest of India



Aamir Khan Vs. Rest of India


A few days back Mr. Aamir Khan made a statement about his wife being worried about the growing intolerance in this country. He also informed us that she is worried about the future of her child.

The day when this interview was published I got seriously enraged and joined the Aamir bashing social media bandwagon and bashed Aamir for his irresponsible behavior.

It’s been a while now and people have gone back to sharing jokes on the social media. This gave me some time to ponder over what happened over the past few weeks, listen to the interview in its totality and arrive at an objective analysis of the whole incident.

By means of this article I am presenting my independent views in the most objective manner, humanly possible for me.

I have broken up the entire debate in three parts,

First, The reasons for this unprovoked public outrage,

Second, Aamir’s right to empress his views, and

Third, Is India an intolerant country or are Indians an intolerant community?

The reasons for this unprovoked public outrage

What could have been the reason for this outrage against seemingly innocuous statement of a mother? In a way all she said was that, I am thinking of leaving India because I am worried about the future of my child. Fair enough, if one is worried and has the means to permanently relocate out of India, he or she is free to do it. After all India is not China and India gives you freedom to accept her as your country or leave it for greener pastures.

People may not have been so worried about such statements in a country where working or relocating to a foreign land is deemed a lucky break. Given an opportunity, people will walk head over heels to go to Europe, USA or Canda. In fact, is it not true that, Satya Nadela, Sundar Pichai, Bobby Jindal are an outcome of this move west frenzy.

We can safely conclude that, people would not have been enraged to this extent, if it would have been a simple case of motherly affection to see her son prosper.

Then, is it a Hindu Vs Muslim issue? I don’t think so. Aamir Khan as well as people of India are smart and open-minded enough to understand that all these issues culminate out of vote bank politics and would not spend time, effort and energy on these futile issues.

Goes without saying, India treats everyone equally. The roads are bad for everyone, the air is polluted for everyone, the life is good or miserable for everyone and each and every citizen is given equal opportunity to be a Naryan Murty, a Dhiru Bhai Ambani, a Dawood Ibrahim or an Arun Gawli. So it is not a matter of religious fervor that stoked this kind of response on social media.

So it is not this neither that, then what is the reason for such a an outrage,.

The reason for outrage is much deeper and Mr. Aamir Khan on this occasion failed to read it right.

While deliberating on this issue he, knowingly or unknowingly, struck a wrong note.

The people were angry because he asked a question about, India and the collective ability of this country to provide a livable and safe habitat.

This is a country whose very existence was doubted. British in 1947 believed that this country will be fragmented into a 100 pieces in 25 years and will not be able to sustain itself. They as well as the world had been proved wrong, as this country not only survived, thrived, but also prospered. The country is so diverse that the same language is spoken in 7 different ways across its own home state, the same god is worshipped in 50 different manners across a district and everyone is different from his neighbor. Then, is it not a wonder, that Sandeep Unnikrishnan, of Keral is ready to die for unrelated and unknown people of Maharashtra who are absolutely dissimilar to himself. Just think about the challenges faced by the founding fathers of this nation. Gandhi, Patel, Nehru, Bose, Rajaji, Maulana and many such people have ensured that all of us are bound together by this unknown, invisible, bond of Indianity. The force that binds us together is the belief that we are a country and being Indian comes first.

We may be Hindus, Muslims, Sikhs, Christians, Jains, Buddhists, Marathis, Gujaratis, Tamils, Bengalis, Kashmirs, Assamesse or anything else, but, we are also Indians at the same time.

Mr. Khan forgot this basic premise and walked in a trap of words, he laid out for himself. He failed to realize the outrage he would create by raising the question of India being a livable country.

This to some extent shows his naivety as a statesman, as no seasoned statesman would ever try to touch upon this issue. This public outcry again proved that we are together as a country and it gave me a solace that come what may the integrity of this nation is not in danger.

Jai Hind.